The Lupe Fiasco
Posted by Mic King on Feb 11, 2011 | 7 comments
Please forgive me as I am a week late with this, but the fact that the disgust has lingered long enough for me to still want to write about this is a testament to how weak the idea was. (Edit: I just saw that he is doing this again tonight so I guess I’m still on time.)
Let me first say that I believe Lupe Fiasco is an incredible lyricist so we can be clear that the following is not a Lupe Fiasco hate post. The following is a critique of his Union Square marketing tactic.
For those that are unaware, Lupe posted a rather ambiguous (read: misleading) tweet on February 3rd that was a Call to Action for his NYC fans. I’ll let him show you in his own words:
Granted this could mean anything, but being that Lupe just recently rallied his supporters to march across NYC and convince Atlantic Records to release “Lasers” from purgatory (catch up here) it’s fair to say the fans expected something more. Musicians oftentimes use ambiguous tweets such as these to clue people in to secret shows or secret giveaways. What Lupe was gave us was far short of that.
I wasn’t there but here’s a firsthand account of what took place and fan reaction:
“At 7 pm, fans began to “look up in the sky” as Lupe told them to — but there was nothing to be seen. Ten minutes went by as fans started to fake Lupe sightings in the crowd. Then an ambulance pulled up to the curb and chaos erupted. Some fans thought Lupe was inside the ambulance and began to charge towards it. People slipped on the icy Union Square steps. Lupe then tweeted again…”
“All the fans left the ambulance and moved into the streets. Cars were blocked off immediately and another ambulance was temporarily unable to get through. On the side of the building that DSW Warehouse is in, an image was projected onto the building. It was Lupe’s Twitter icon, a QR code.”
“The QR Code flashed and played previews for what looked like a music video — with no sound. People began to walk away very quickly to say the least.”
“This event is an example of extreme marketing of the worst kind, purely promotional with no benefit to the artist’s fans. Just earlier that day, Lupe had released the tracklist to the album. Why couldn’t he have waited and projected that onto a Union Square wall? There was no real point in holding this event at all. Lupe probably pissed off more fans than he won over that night. As someone who walked away screamed: “I’m downloading this album for free. This was bullshit.”
Can we all agree that this is a failure? Well that’s fine if you and I can’t because it seems that at least Lupe has learned his lesson:
However, that’s just the back story; the much bigger issue here is that the whole idea is an expensive exercise in futility. The QR just takes you to a link to pre-order “Lasers” with extras for $50. Really, Lupe? You activated your loyal supporters to come out during one of the harshest winters in recent memory to jump through hoops to look at some pictures and then over-pay for your album?! Seriously, fire your marketing agency immediately (lucky for them I can’t remember the name). You could have accomplished the same thing with a better ROI using your media buy on Facebook ads that pointed to a landing page with the very same thing.
The case could be made that then I wouldn’t be writing this right now.
I get that, but at what cost? I assure you Lupe Fiasco fans will think twice now before considering leaving the comfort of their homes when he issues his next calls to action. Most of the coverage about this is negative and given the response I’m positive they would have gotten a better ROI buying a Myspace ad. Yes, I just said Myspace in 2011. Yes, no one uses that. Yes, that is my point. This was a grandiose exercise in futility.
The Lupe Solution
I have a much better idea but let me first familiarize you with the concept of a “dead drop.”
In short, there is a German guy who started cutting holes in walls and placing USB flash drives in them and sealing them back up for use as an offline peer-to-peer file sharing network. Applying this to Lupe, he should have released a mixtape or some sort of exclusive release in conjunction with the announcement of the pre-order of his album and then placed dead drops in various places in various cities. Each city would get one song and some other piece of multimedia content, perhaps a video or something with instructions to visit a portal on Lupe’s site that you would not otherwise know how to reach. Users would then have to talk amongst each themselves across some sort of social network on Lupe’s site and share the songs. Lupe’s site is where the pre-ordering should occur, not while dodging ambulances in Union Square.
Now the QR code would have been great to use in conjunction with this idea. It would have acted as a bat signal and it should have changed to a different code every 10 seconds that would have shown you a different location in Red Laser (to spread out the volume of people). Every location would be a dead drop with Lupe Fiasco “Lasers” branding as a graffiti stencil on the wall to let you know you had arrived. However they could have skipped the expensive ad altogether and Lupe could have just tweeted locations and clues and accomplished the very same thing.
My idea is very involved but the benefits include qualified site traffic, email addresses/facebook/twitter info for the mailing list and sharing of via social network signup, extensive chatter across other networks/cities/states/countries as people traded the songs to get the complete set. Fans would also feel more inclined to pre-order the new album since Lupe did something really cool and gave them something in return. Secondary benefits would have been the extensive positive coverage this would have gotten on not just hiphop blogs but tech and marketing blogs as well.
Lupe Fiasco could have changed the game; instead he gave us a really expensive and boring light show that will forever be known amongst would-be bloggers and marketers as The Lupe Fiasco.
I have plenty more great ideas where that came from. Lupe, please feel free to email me, let’s talk about making your album campaign work: firstname.lastname@example.org. Everyone else, follow me on Twitter – @iPullRank
About the Guest Author
1 Ughhh says...
First of all, if you were a true Lu fan, then you would have realized he wasn't going to be there since he was in Australia.
Second, this marketing tactic is very innovative and (using actual stats to prove it) has been VERY successful so far
Third, dead drop wouldn't work, imagine hundreds of lupe fans arriving at the scene fighting and pushing each other to download it (the USB would probably even break off).
Also you do realize that anyone passing by the projection has the ability to scan it, right?
Anyways, you might think its a failure, but I have hardcore data and numbers that prove otherwise.
Posted at 10:25 a.m. on February 12, 2011
2 ipullrank says...
I never claimed to be a hardcore Lupe fan and even so his hardcore fans didn't seem to know he wouldn't be there either.
Innovation, yeah I guess but again what did his fans get out of it? They got to travel into the cold for a chance to pay more for his album. It'd be diferent if a Spring day when everyone was out anyway.
You do realize your condescencion is a waste of everyone's time, right?
Just share the analytics and prove me wrong.
Posted at 1:08 p.m. on February 12, 2011
I think this is a great example of what analytics won't tell you. I've done years of work in internet marketing now, and the focus on CONVERSION blinds people to the invisible costs: like pissing off your own customers, for instance. That's something you're not going to get impressions, CTR counts and bounce rates for. And when you read over the responses on Twitter & elsewhere, there were a lot of people vocally disappointed and even angry.
Is that just the cost of doing business? I don't think there's any easy answer there, but it's an important question to chew over in 2011.
This is a stunt that looked cool on tech blogs after the fact, but it was a letdown for many of the fans who were actually there. I think that qualifies as using people. They could have been used better, more charitably, more equitably, more honestly.
Just my opinion, based on facts that are already on record here.
Posted at 3:31 p.m. on February 12, 2011
4 ipullrank says...
I definitely agree with that.
However if this guy who is obviously someone connected to the campaign can show me that they got a million pre-orders then I'm wrong, it worked...buuuuuuuuut we both know he can't so my points stand.
And to address the volume of people issue...surely it's no different than what happened on a release date when 200 people lined up at Tower Records for a chance at 50 copies of a release? And even so, Lupe is not Drake. Roughly 200 people came out for his march. A few hundred came out for Union Square. As I suggested there would be multiple locations displayed with the QR code.
But yeah the general consensus is that the intended audience was let down and the brand was tarnished. Bad marketing. The end.
Posted at 4:25 p.m. on February 12, 2011
5 Andy O'Connor says...
Analytics, huh? Well, I was there. It was a huge letdown, period. Everyone around me thought it was bullshit and people turned around and left as soon as we realized that was it.
I think Justin's comment is dead-on, this was for Mashable and TechCrunch headlines, not his actual fans. Maybe I'm not really a fan, though, since I don't know what country Lupe is in, every day of the year. If that first comment is really from Lupe's team, that's terrible, he sounds arrogant and out of touch. Not a good look, and if anything it makes things look even worse.
Posted at 5:05 p.m. on February 12, 2011
6 Young J says...
Great article but I don't think the dead drop is NECESARILY the right solution, there's a lot of other options too. I never woulda known about the dead drop concept without this though so thanks for that man
Posted at 5:48 a.m. on February 13, 2011
7 Thomas says...
I understand what you guys are saying. However, my common sense says why would any adult stand out in the cold for "some sign" from a rapper? I don't get it and wouldn't do it.
Posted at 2:12 p.m. on February 13, 2011